Twin tree towers burning

I'm not sure what to think of this ad. It was created for an environmental organization and shows two trees standing side by side, their trunks smoking and spewing flames like the Twin Towers on September 11, 2001. The text on the ad reads: "For nature, everyday is 9/11."

Setting aside the argument of whether or not the ad is insensitive, or if it's too soon to evoke such images, I wonder if the ad actually makes a clear point. I understand it wants to demonstrate how the environment is "under attack," but there are no specifics. The idea of comparing it to 9/11 may be jarring and controversial, which is obviously the point, but I want more detail. I want to know exactly how the events of that day and our treatment of the environment are similar. I have no problem with an ad trying to shock people, but such an ad would have a much larger impact if it was more obvious why such a connection is being made.

Reader Comments

(Page 1)
Features
The Standing Eight (4)
The Apprentice (2)
AdAge in 60 Seconds (264)
Online Ad Checklist (1)
Ads We Love (37)
Ads We Hate (32)
Previously on WIN (12)
Events
Super Bowl 2006 (82)
Super Bowl 2005 (63)
Super Bowl 2007 (37)
Topic
Agencies (464)
Awards (63)
Budgets (232)
Campaign Launch (397)
Celebrities (244)
Controversies (450)
Copycats (26)
Corporate (460)
Executive Shifts (22)
Flickr Fiend (38)
Funny (1010)
Gripes (784)
Networks (58)
Op-ed (335)
Product Placement (305)
Sexy (202)
Viral (200)
Medium
Consumer Generated (52)
On Spec (1)
Streaming Video (309)
Video Game (33)
Video on Demand (12)
Word of Mouth (22)
DVR (39)
Indoor (383)
Online (2090)
Outdoor (731)
Podcasts (22)
Print (1106)
Radio (254)
RSS (16)
Search (72)
Television (2357)
Wireless (59)

RESOURCES

RSS NEWSFEEDS

Powered by Blogsmith